With the opening of the movie, Harry Potter and the Deathy Hallows, Part 1, I’ve noticed a substantial increase in the number of people coming here to read a post I did last year about J.K. Rowling’s writing style. For those of you who didn’t see it the first time, I’m re-running a slightly modified version of the original today to make it easier to find. If you’ve read it before, maybe you’ll find some new meaning in it after seeing the movie.
If you’ve read the books and seen “Happy Potter and the Deathy Hallows Part I,” how did the movie’s script compare with the writing in the book? Was it better, worse, or just different?
Feel free to share other comments you have about Rowling’s writing process to add to the discussion.
***
I came late to Harry Potter. I’d seen the movies but hadn’t picked up the books. That is, not until May 2009 when my then 8-year-old started reading them. I figured I should too, to help him with the scary parts.
I got hooked. I read at lunch. I read instead of watching TV. When I finished a book late one night I sneaked into my son’s room to get the next one, so anxious to keep reading I couldn’t make it until the next day.
After two months of Harry Potter immersion, I finished all seven books, then found myself scouring author J.K. Rowling’s official website and blog, and fan sites like MuggleNet and The Leaky Cauldron and watching documentaries to learn more about the woman behind the story and the publishing phenomenon.
Rowling’s success isn’t news to Harry Potter fans. Even before I read the books I knew the highlights: single mom on the dole gets inspired, sells first book, goes on to become one of the most-published authors ever, and possibly the richest. But I didn’t know much about Rowling’s writing process, which is worth sharing with anyone who makes a living with their words.
Here’s what Rowling and my Harry Potter experience taught me about writing:
1. Persistence counts. Rowling got the idea for the Harry Potter in 1990 and spent the next 17 years working on it before finishing Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows in 2007. Seventeen years – that’s as long as it takes a kid to go from kindergarten through high school.
The takeaway: You may start out loving a project but the day may come – days, weeks or months into it – you’re so bored, frustrated or fed up you want to scream or put it away forever. But look what can happen if you gut it out.
2. Think things through. Rowling wrote in the biography on her website that she was on a train when the idea for Harry Potter “fell into my head.” She didn’t have paper or pen, so for the four-hour train ride all she could do was think. Her forced rumination could have saved the series: “I think that perhaps if I had had to slow down the ideas so that I could capture them on paper I might have stifled some of them,” she’s said.
The take away: Don’t be too quick to get something down on paper. Think about the structure, the concepts, the conclusions and the way you want something to play out before committing it to paper.
3. If the story’s good enough, the writing can be secondary. Face it, Rowling isn’t Hemingway. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone isn’t Beowulf. The writing in the first books in the series was downright pedestrian. But with that story, who could resist? I couldn’t. UPDATE: As many readers of the original post pointed out, Rowling’s writing did improve along the way. You could even say it grew up along with her characters. And who says you have to be Hemingway to be good?
The takeaway: Got a good story to tell? Tell it. If you write enough, you’ll get better on your own. Rowling did in her later books.
4. Go for it. Rowling was a struggling single mom when she started Harry Potter. She had no clips, no publishing industry connections, no platform.
The takeaway: It takes persistence, passion and a little Harry Potter-style bravura to believe in yourself enough to take on the publishing world as an novice writer – which may explain why many beginning writers flock sell themselves short by working for a pittance for less-than stellar publishers and websites. Could someone replicate Rowling’s rise to author stardom given what it takes to get a book published today? I’d like to hope so.
5. Write when you’re on. Rowling likes to write through the night, or in cafes with just enough people and music to get lost in. When she was finishing “Deathly Hallows” she checked into a hotel room so she could write the ending with no distractions.
The takeaway: You might not be able to afford a hotel room or pull an all nighter, especially if you have kids to get off to school the next morning. But you can structure your work day so you’re writing during your peak energy time, whenever that happens to be.
6. Don’t be afraid to make things complicated. The Harry Potter series is a thicket of characters, subplots and themes – all in what are supposed to be children’s fantasy novels.
The takeaway: Give your readers – even young ones – credit for their intelligence. Don’t dumb down your ideas, or your writing.
7. Leave stuff out. In 2007 British documentary on Rowling that re-aired when movie version of Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince opened, the author shares details of her characters that never made it into the books, including back stories and what happens in their lives after the books ends. The tidbits either didn’t fit into the plot or weren’t interesting enough to be included (although fans live for this kind of stuff). UPDATE: Rowling has hinted in recent interviews that she might be open to the possibility of continuing the saga in future books.
The takeaway: Pick the most telling details, the juiciest quotes, the most spot-on examples to tell your story and leave the rest out, especially if – unlike Rowling – you’re writing to a specific word count.
8. Write what you love. Rowling obvious loves her Harry Potter universe – she wouldn’t have drawn up the family tree shown on that British TV documentary with details of who Harry, Ron and Hermione go on to marry after the conclusion of the books.
The takeaway: Enjoy what you do and how you do it, otherwise, why do it at all?
9. Be good to your people. Rowling blogged during and after writing “Deathly Hallows” so readers could find out more about her and the books. Besides book signing and official appearances, she’s also done Q&As with the people who run her fan sites.
The takeaway: We live in an age of interactive media. If you’re writing you need some kind of relationship with your readers, whether it’s on a blog, Twitter, book signings or all of the above. Depending on what you do, you can use the interaction to shape what you write, or build an audience for your next project.
10. It’s OK to goof off. After she gave up cigarettes, Rowling took up Minesweeper, the game Microsoft bundles with Windows, when she needed a writing break. She got so good she even brags on her blog about her expert-level times.
The takeaway: If Rowling can play mindless computer games for a little mental R&R, it’s OK if you check Twitter or Facebook during the work day. UPDATE: Reading about Rowling playing Minesweeper made me miss the old game, so I started playing again. Bad idea. One thing led to another and before long I was spending too much time on Minesweeper, Free Cell and Spider Solataire. I’ve re-instituted a self-imposed ban on computer games. Maybe you’re more strong willed, but once I start I can’t stop.
Michael W. Perry says
Don’t let J. K. Rowling know that you described her as a “single mom on the dole.” Her time on the dole was short, in part, the result of a divorce, and came several years after her initial inspiration for the tale on a rail trip. And before all of that, she studied French and Classics at the University of Exeter, hence all the Latin and classical allusions in her tales.
I suspect this oft-repeated ‘single mom on the dole’ story is why the magical press gets treated so roughly in her novels. In that she’s not alone. Both J. R. R. Tolkien and C. S. Lewis, who also wrote fantasy, had a similar disdain for literary critics who tried to find the meaning of their fiction in their biographies.
–Michael W. Perry, author of Untangling Tolkien.
Michelle V. Rafter says
Michael, thank you so much for stopping by, and for your additional insights into Rowling’s work and success.
Michelle
Jessie Mac says
Thanks Michelle for sharing the post. Having just watched the film, it was good to find out these small facts about JK Rowling. I enjoyed the film and her books and like everyone else find her journey as writer fascinating.
marya writes says
I really enjoyed reading this post. For some reason, I haven’t been able to get into any Harry Potter books. My husband is the one who has read them cover to cover, and he doesn’t read, period. My kids are too young but I am sure not before long, my 7 year old (gifted reader) will be completely taken over by the first book. Then he can tell me what I have been missing. 🙂
Michelle V. Rafter says
Marya, I started reading the HP books to my youngest, then when his reading took off we read them together (silently to ourselves but at the same time). He beat me through all seven books, but only by a month or so. My husband read the first book along with our older kids but didn’t pick up the second book until last year and is finally making his way through “Deathly Hallows” so he can finish it before the last movie’s out.
MVR
marya writes says
Thanks for your reply. Maybe there is hope for me yet then? 🙂
Mac Overmyer says
You noted that Ms Rowling’s style improved as the tale progressed. I suspect that some of this can be attributed to experience and age, but I also suspect that a lot of it came from working closely with a good editor.
Michelle V. Rafter says
Thanks – quite a few people have criticized me about that comment, but I still hold to it. And I agree with you that the improvement probably has to do with age and experience and better editing. If the first book was published in 1997 and she worked on it some years before that, it means Rowling spent at least a dozen years on the series. As a writer, I would hope that I’d improve over the span of that many years. And as she got more successful, her publisher probably teamed her up with more high profile, experienced, editors and other staff.
Michelle
Seth ryan rawlings says
Hi my name is seth i’mn 9.Why do you have to stop writing harry potter?Please pretty please don’t stop it is really really good and alot of people are dissapointed.So please don’t stop .
Brimshack says
Heh, …if the story is good. Reminds me a bit of Tolkein. I tried reading a bit of The Lord of Rings recently. The actual page-to-page writing was nothing spectacular. It’s the overall narrative that drew people in.