10 responses to “If you're upgrading your writing career, j-school isn't the answer”

  1. stephanerd

    Great post Michelle! After getting our undergraduate degrees, many friends and acquaintances started looking at grad school, some as a continuation of their education…some because they still felt directionless…

    To me, grad school has never seemed necessary. Why get a degree to write, when I’ve already been writing for years!?

    With determination and initiative, fledgling writers can get pretty far, without spending thousands of dollars for an M.A. or M.F.A. Research, networking, pitching…the occasional continuing education course…I’ve always thought it best to learn by doing.

  2. Stephanie

    Just out of curiosity, what does the academic side of journalism entail? Is it similar to an MA in MassComm?

  3. Doreen Howell

    Yes. I agree. A writing portfolio covering the various styles you are interested in will take you where you want to go.

  4. Kimberly Sallingboe

    Thanks for the post. I just discovered your blog, but I’m already hooked. I have a BA in English and have often toyed with the idea of going back for my Masters in Journalism, basically for the same reasons you covered in your post: a desire for legitimacy, the need to be on equal-footing with the agencies I work with, etc. Now I’m trying to get serious about freelancing, after stumbling into it accidentally, and your blog provides a lot of helpful tips for us newbies. Thanks again.

  5. Melissa

    Hey everyone. I’m actually an MSJ student at Medill. Oddly enough, I’m not here because I want the typical news job…I think I want something more in the way of management/communications, but I thought I needed to understand the journalism business. I also wanted new media training, and I’m taking media management courses through the Kellogg business school. For me, graduate school was a good choice because in addition to (hopefully) getting ahead in my career, I hope to one day teach at a university. So I guess it’s all about your own personal goals and what you want to do with your career. I’m lucky in that Medill allows me to sort of branch out and explore a lot of my interests, which is kind of what I wanted out of a j-school.

  6. Michelle Rafter

    My thoughts exactly. Right out of college I felt like I needed the validation of a MA to be a real journalist. Although I had a good experience in grad school, I quickly realized what I really needed was the kind of on the job training that no school can give you.

    Michelle Rafter

  7. Michelle Rafter

    Programs differ. Some are tailored to people whose BAs were in a different subject & are learning journalism for the first time – those programs have lots of basic instruction on reporting, writing, etc., plus classes on ethics, etc. Others are heavier on research and journalism/communications theory and require students to do some type of thesis paper/project. Some are a blend of the two.

  8. Michelle Rafter

    Good point Doreen – and all the more reason to have your portfolio posted somewhere online, be it at your own Website or blog or on the Website of a writers’ association or group that provides such a service, like MediaBistro.com, Author’s Guild, ASJA, FreelanceSuccess.com, etc.

  9. Michelle Rafter

    Good luck Kimberly. There are many opportunities for mid-career training that don’t require going back for a full MA, hope you can take advantage of some of them. The best training, though, is to do lots and lots of writing. Good luck.

    Michelle R.

  10. Michelle Rafter

    Melissa: You’ve listed some great reasons for going to j-school, and I agree 100 percent that the decision mus be based on one’s personal goals. I just don’t think j-school is the only avenue, especially if someone already has some training and doesn’t see academia or management in their immediate future. On the other hand, I could see how the current economic climate might make school an appealing option to pounding the pavement for a full-time news gig.

Leave a Reply

Michelle V. Rafter

Reporting and blogging about business, tech and media.

Add to Technorati Favorites
Blogroll Online Writers Groups Professional Organizations Resources Where I Write Writers

The Blogathon is coming! The Blogathon is coming! The 3rd annual WordCount Blogathon is just around the corner. This May, freelancers, writers and bloggers of all stripes are invited to join me in a blogging marathon - posting 31 days straight. This year's Blothathon promises to be better than ever, with participant badges, giveaways, a guest-post exchange, and real-time recap. Look for more details coming soon. Meanwhile, check out Blogathon resources here. Read. Comment. Enjoy.